Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We鈥檒l occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

nerfs silver extracts #6629

Merged
merged 1 commit into from May 21, 2022
Merged

Conversation

zeskorion
Copy link
Contributor

About The Pull Request

silver extracts now only spawn 1 food or drink items, instead of 5 to 6 items
silver extracts can no longer spawn gatfruit or roburgers

Why It's Good For The Game

Xenobio shouldnt be able to walk into the bar with a bag of silver extracts and render the chef and bartender completely useless with a bit of plasma.

roburger nanomachines shouldnt be obtainable in reagent form, gatfruit can majorly throw off round balance if given to botany

Changelog

馃啈
balance: silver extracts now only spawn one item
balance: silver extracts can no longer spawn gatfruit or roburgers
/:cl:

@Mat05usz
Copy link
Contributor

Mat05usz commented Apr 9, 2022

Gatfruit spam almost never happens, it's a rare thing and because of that it usually applies just the right amount of chaos to the round (and it's fun that it can happen, you know what's that?). Before yesterday, the last time I saw gatfruit spam was on Golden, so quite some time ago (and even before that, it was very rare) so it's a non issue from the game/RP point of view.

And roboburgers, like what. At this point you're just removing fun and rare stuff from the game because yes.

@zeskorion
Copy link
Contributor Author

Gatfruit spam almost never happens, it's a rare thing and because of that it usually applies just the right amount of chaos to the round (and it's fun that it can happen, you know what's that?). Before yesterday, the last time I saw gatfruit spam was on Golden, so quite some time ago (and even before that, it was very rare) so it's a non issue from the game/RP point of view.

And roboburgers, like what. At this point you're just removing fun and rare stuff from the game because yes.

When someone figures out how to do stuff like this, you often cannot trust players to not keep doing it. I nerf stuff that's bad for balance when it's complained about in the discord, as that's the sign players know about it

@Mat05usz
Copy link
Contributor

Mat05usz commented Apr 9, 2022

When someone figures out how to do stuff like this, you often cannot trust players to not keep doing it. I nerf stuff that's bad for balance when it's complained about in the discord, as that's the sign players know about it

Just because something happened once, doesn't mean it should outright be removed. It's not game breaking, as much as mass ordering lasers isn't either, maybe add some logging for admins so they can easily figure out who's responsible for the spam, but don't remove the feature.

@RDS88-beeman
Copy link
Contributor

gunspam is gunspam, and gatfruit spam (in theory) requires a botanist with a brain, a xenobiologist with a brain, like 20 minutes with max brain of just growing the fucking plant, and then security needs to not do their fucking jobs and arrest the people with contraband revolvers, as opposed to any other kind of gunspam which requires usually one cargo tech with a brain

and like, nanomachines at least let you continue to play the game as a non-simplemob and maybe even get cloned, as opposed to black mutation toxin which has had griefers abusing it for weeks, and since you removed any and all nuance with that chem the only reason it still has to exist is

haha funny decarbon syringe.

which as I think you put it best yourself, "is basically just instant death"

@williamcll
Copy link
Contributor

How about 5 rare ingredients instead? silvers still generate food that are often at time impossible for a chef to make without understanding or cooperation with botany and cargo.

@pricklytomato
Copy link

Xenobio shouldnt be able to walk into the bar with a bag of silver extracts and render the chef and bartender completely useless with a bit of plasma.

Silver extracts don't really make either useless, I really like using silver extracts as a bartender to try to get a few of the rarer ingredients for drinks (especially since for whatever reason you can't grow peaches for Blazaam). The only real impact that silver slimes have on the chef is maybe access to some random new meats from humanoids, and food that they wouldn't have been able to make because botany is being lazy or food that wouldn't have been able to be made that round.

Also technically both the chef and bartender are completely useless because you can both just get booze yourself from the bar and you can just buy food at vending machines. The difference is that you can get better food/drinks with someone you'd at least expect to know what they're doing

gatfruit can majorly throw off round balance if given to botany

The only time I've seen gatfruit being spammed on the station is whenever miners steal the packet of seeds form living terrariums and give it to botany.

Overall, I think crippling them just leads to more frustrations with the bartender and chef trying to get botany to do their job and grow more than just acid/BS tomatoes and weed. If you're worried about gatfruit and the roboburger (which I think I've seen spawn once from using silver extract) just decrease the chances of getting it, I already assume they're ridiculously low because I haven't even been able to get a gatfruit when using silver extracts.

@Lagomorphica
Copy link

Out of everything that xenobiology has that is strong, this is definitely rather low on the list. Roburgers, with their instant kill attribute with virus food speeding it up, are already slated to be modified to not do that; and even if it does occur, cyborgification can be reversed if other crew is competent.

Ultimately, this is not 'it', as they say, chief.

@Xerkie
Copy link

Xerkie commented Apr 16, 2022

roburger has literally no use other than grief and annoying people
gatfruit spam has literally no use other than grief and ruining antag rounds
"it's a low chance, so it's ok" is not an excuse for allowing awfully imbalanced shit
chef & bartender should have to actually do their jobs instead of having a magical industrial core that spawns piles and piles of the best food and drinks in the game upon giving them plasma
good pr

@St0rmC4st3r
Copy link
Contributor

chef and bartender completely useless

An alternative source of variable products for the chef other than botany and cargo would be nice. Botany is good at mass producing stuff when they cooperate, but do almost nothing when they don't, cargo doesn't cover the cases where you need multiple of one specific ingredient.

chef & bartender should have to actually do their jobs instead of having a magical industrial core that spawns piles and piles of the best food and drinks in the game upon giving them plasma

Remove crossbreeds then?

roburger has literally no use other than grief and annoying people

Except also a funny antag gimmick. If you REALLY want to deal with the roburger issue, make the roburgers giving nanomachines only when eaten.

gatfruit spam

As Pricklytomato said, stealing seeds from the terrarium is much more common. It is not as reliable as grinding (no, the other type of grinding) silver extracts, but requires much less effort.

Bad PR. Please try some other approach.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

None yet

10 participants